Synopsis
My Mistress is an Australian drama that elegantly navigates the dual themes of desire and mourning. Executive-produced by Stephen Lance, the film interweaves the themes of loss, trauma, and strife within the beautiful imagery of the movie. It follows the story of a 16-year-old boy Charlie Boyd, who is played by Harrison Gilbertson, a lad who is emotionally broken by the shock and horror of the death of his father. This life-altering event shatters Charlie’s emotional world into a fog of confusion, guilt, and numbness on all fronts.
Charlie’s emotional world and grieving heart are so solitary and alone that he gives into his emptiness and surrenders to anguishing pain. This emotional world of his is disintegrating ever slowly and steadily and the traumatic event of losing one’s father brings him to lose the father figure in every sense of the word. Struggling to connect with his mother and unable to communicate his anger and grief at the world, he begins to act out from grief. His desperate wanderings lead him to a semi-derelict part of his suburb where he meets a delusional French woman living nearby.
Maggie, played by Emmanuelle Béart, is far from an eccentric neighbor who keeps to herself. As a dominatrix, her profession is to perform BDSM fantasies where she takes on the role of a sexual master of her clients. Charlie, while quite averse to seeking her services, finds himself increasingly drawn to his interactions with her. He visits her not for intimacy, but to begin a complicated process of somewhat ambiguous therapeutic ‘healing.’
Although their relationship grows, it remains awkwardly positioned somewhere between therapy and something inappropriate. For Charlie, he views Maggie as an emotionally neutral partner who can provide the boundaries he craves in a relationship, even as he becomes entrenched in her bondage and discipline world. In contrast, Maggie is sympathetic: emotionally distant and loveless herself, jaded and detached. Yet Charlie’s suffering brings a certain recognition to her—perhaps in the form of her younger self, wounded and searching in a world that lacks certainty.
This story avoids a simple romantic or erotic approach and focuses on the deep introspection of how trauma manifests and how unlikely relationships can lead to healing. While the relationship between Charlie and Maggie may be considered taboo, the film does not try to sensationalize it. Instead, it portrays their bond as emotionally raw and complex.
The film also examines the themes of dominance and submission both literally and figuratively. Charlie, the young and disoriented character, attempts to let go of control over his life and spirals into confusion, while experienced dominatrix Maggie loses her grip, allowing herself to soften emotionally. Their evolving connection does not stem from sexual fulfillment but rather from shared compassion.
The visual aspects of the film contribute to the sorrowful aura with muted colors. The pacing is slow and reflects the characters’ emotions. The viewer is drawn into a world that is sensual but not exploitative and intimate yet distant, thanks to Geoffrey Simpson’s cinematography.
The film’s climactic moments are unresolved. Like many aspects of life, grief is complex and far from linear. Instead of a neatly packaged resolution, the characters achieve a rather imperfect emotional ceasefire. For both Charlie and Maggie, there is some form of interdependence with regard to their grief: Maggie permits Charlie to confront and start working through his grief, while in return, Charlie rekindles some ability to feel in Maggie.
Cast & Crew
Director: Stephen Lance
Writers: Gerard Lee (co-writer), Stephen Lance (co-writer)
Cinematographer: Geoffrey Simpson
Music: David Hirschfelder
Main Cast: Emmanuelle Béart as Maggie: A French actress who starred in Manon des Sources and 8 Women, Emmanuelle brings a subtle pain and mysterious depth to her role as a dominatrix. She serves at the emotional anchor of the film.
Harrison Gilbertson as Charlie Boyd: Gilbertson shines as the grief-stricken teen. His performance highlights the struggle of a purposeless young man who lost his father, capturing confusion, pain, and desperation.
Rachael Blake as Kate Boyd: As the widow and mother to Charlie. Kate is depicted in the film as distant and emotionally vacant, overwhelmed with life after her husband’s suicide. Through the character, Blake brings tension and quiet grief, depicting a woman striving to keep her broken family intact.
Socratis Otto as Leon: In the role of Leon, Otto contributes as a minor character in Maggie’s universe, enhancing the dominatrix’s world while simultaneously revealing aspects of Maggie’s history.
Ratings and Reviews from IMDb and Others
My Mistress appears to have a highly controversial reception, reflected in a 5.5/10 rating on IMDb, indicating that evaluators in that platform are very divided on the film. Some people appreciated the pervasive emotional atmosphere and character dynamics, whereas others found the film’s pacing and themes unpleasant.
Critics also seemed divided on the ethics and the emotional dynamics of the interaction between the adult sexualized woman and the teenage boy protagonist. While some thought the film did quite a bit in terms of restraint and subtlety, others were harsher, claiming it was irresponsible for attempting sensitive material without consideration for its implications.
What emerged was lack of consensus about the elegant visuals, Shutter Island’s main actress Emmanuelle Béart was praised for what is considered one of her most intricate performances in years, while Gilbertson’s portrayal of adolescent grief was recognized for the maturity he injected into Maggie’s character.
Furthermore, blending images and sound, David Hirschfelder aided the film’s emotive atmosphere furnishing a minimalist rendition that enhances rather than drags attention from the visuals and dialogues.
Conclusion
Not every viewer is likely to appreciate My Mistress. It goes to difficult places that intertwine grief with sexuality and healing. It poses more questions than it answers, exploring concepts like boundaries, emotional wounds, and comfort in its myriad forms. It’s a very slow film, almost meditative in nature, and demands empathy and patience from its viewers.
Those who seek more from cinema than easy entertainment will find My Mistress a haunting experience. It’s about what remains unsaid as much as what is presented and continues to resonate long after the credits roll. It defies easy labeling—a coming of age film it is not, and erotic drama it does not fit. My Mistress occupies a quiet, shadowy corner of cinema.
Watch Free Movies on Onionplay